5 July - 2014- “History is past politics and politics present history.”
|Present Politics and Past History
By Prof. Khatchatur I. Pilikian, EREBOUNI Bilingual – Armenian & English - Biweekly,
London, 27 April 1991
The below commentary, written by Prof. K. Pilikian in 1991, is as relevant today as it was eighteen years ago.--Editor.
“History is past politics and politics present history.”
Sir John Seely, The Growth of British Policy (1895)
Erebouni’s March 30, 1991 editorial, concerning the Treaty of Moscow of March 1921, is titled “A Sad Anniversary”, because the circumstances of that “past politics” is not just singularly sad but important for us to appreciate, and objectively so, the “present history” of our third Armenian Republic.
Having read the editorial, I soon realized, alas, that it was focused outside the liberal and democratic perspectives of the biweekly’s proclaimed politics. The editorial complained that “A delegation, representing the Armenian Communist government…was never admitted to the conference, despite the fact that at the time the Soviet Union had not yet evolved into its present federated and centralised form and therefore Armenia was still a self-governing republic enjoying the right to hold negotiations with other states and to conclude formal treaties,” (Erebouni, No.171, p 5, London)
Concurrently, albeit in another political camp, the telegram of 15 March 1991 sent to the Armenian Supreme Soviet, Yerevan, by the London Branch of the Armenian National Committee and four affiliated Federations and Associations, is yet another message based on historical inaccuracy. Thus, referring to the Treaty of Moscow of March 16, 1921, the telegram reads: “the Soviet-Turkish dishonourable agreement was signed between Bolshevik Armenia and the Turkish government representatives in Moscow…” (Banber, 14 April 1991, p 4, London). Yet, unwittingly, the same Banber has published excerpts of the said Treaty along with the names of the only signatories, that of Soviet Russia and Turkey (ibid, p 5).
But, let us consider facts first.
Writing about the Treaty of Moscow of March 16, 1921, without mentioning the historically crucial “February Uprising” of 1921, is simply futile, if not blatantly misleading. Breaking out on 12 February and lasting nearly two months, the fratricidal adventure claimed not only 20 thousand Armenian deaths (mostly communists and Dashnaks) but re-established in Yerevan, on 18 February, the old guards of the first Armenian Republic.
Having thus toppled momentarily the eleven weeks old Soviet Armenia (the second Armenian Republic), the “Committee for the Liberation of the Fatherland” under the leadership of Simon Vratsian, hastened to ask for Turkish military aid (March 1st) against Soviet forces in Armenia. Moreover, while negotiations were being held in Moscow among the representatives of Soviet Armenia, Soviet Russia, and Turkey, Simon Vratsian sent off two fatal telegrams:
1. - March 12, 1921, to Soviet Russia’s Foreign Minister, Chicherin, claiming that Begzadian, the Foreign Minister and head of the delegation representing Soviet Armenia at the ongoing Moscow conference, has no legal powers to represent Armenia, also because the new government of Yerevan accepts the Treaty of Alexandropol, therefore Armenia has no border dispute with Turkey.
2. - March 15, 1921, to the Foreign Affairs Committee of Turkey’s Grand National Congress, declaring close friendship between Armenia and Turkey, while asking and hoping to get Turkey’s financial and military aid to crush the Armenian bolsheviks, and that Armenia solemnly accepts the Treaty of Alexandropol as the basis for normal, international and friendly relations between the two countries.
Hence the Treaty of Moscow was signed on March 16, 1921, without Begzadian, or any other Armenian official for that matter, on the specific request of Simon Vratsian on behalf of the “Committee for the Liberation of the Fatherland”.
Furthermore, on March 26, 1921, Simon Vratsian sent yet another telegram, this time to the Allied powers at the London Conference, declaring that Armenia is willing to live in peace and friendship with Turkey, wishing also that the decisions of the London Conference will not cause mistrust and displeasure between Turkey and Armenia.
Paradoxically, the first Armenian Republic’s own representative at the London Conference, Avedis Aharonian, was trying in vain to reject the Treaty of Alexandropol, thus acting against the wishes of Vratsian, Aharonian was a signatory of the Treaty of Sevres (August 10, 1920) which the Treaty of Alexandropol, four months later, had come to reject.
The late Kersam Aharonian, one of the most prominent Liberal Democrat politicians of the Armenian Diaspora, was right to conclude: “as a result of the political immaturity of the Leaders of the February Uprising […] the Turks secured a fait accompli”. And that “fait accompli” was to be ratified in Kars on Oct. 13, 1921, with the added signatures of the representatives of Soviet Armenia (re-established on April 2, 1921), Soviet Georgia, and, lo and behold, Soviet Azerbaijan.
Of course, the essence of the tragic sequence of treaties which enabled the Panturkists to usurp more Armenian Lands and cause more Armenian massacres, was formed in Batum on June 4, 1918, just three years after the Armenian Genocide of 1915 and the confiscation of the whole of Western Armenia. On Dec2, 1920, it was highlighted in Alexandropol, albeit illegally (Khatisian’s signature being that of a superseded government, thus never ratified). And because of the “February Uprising” of 1921, it was revoked in Moscow on March 16, 1921, to be finally sealed in Kars on Oct. 13, 1921.
But now in 1991, the vital and crucial questions still remain. Are we repeating historical blunders with our own present politics? While initiating a rapprochement with Turkey but excluding Armenia from the All-Union Plebiscite of March 17, 1991, did the third Republic of Armenia miss an opportunity not to repeat the crushing “fait accompli” of march 16, 1921, when Armenia was excluded from its own border disputes because of the don quixotic infatuations of self indulgent Armenian leaders (whether Dashnak or Communist) with the Pan Turkic arch-enemy turned “comrade”? Are the resurgent nationalist leaders of Armenia today yielding to the pressures of extreme right Independence-fanatics, latter-day religious heretics, new Race-devotees, born-again Christian fundamentalists, free-market racketeers etc, etc to let loose an already weakened Armenia in the economic jaws of Panturanic racism recently “baptised” as Turkish Commonwealth to include Crimea, Caucasus, Azerbaijan, Central Asia, and much more? Can Armenia ever exist in a Turkish Commonwealth?
Armenians cannot afford forgetting that Pan Turkism in action has always meant annihilation of Armenians and confiscation of Armenian Lands.
We must not let historical events repeat genocidal crimes against humanity. People make history also by choice, more so by free choice.
We do have yet another chance to choose our present history for a better future, on September 21, 1991, with the third Armenian Republic’s own Plebiscite
Your rating: None Average: 5 (5 votes)
3845 reads Share this
Post new comment
Keghart.com edits comments for grammatical and spelling errors, obscenity, libelous, offensive and confrontational expressions. Please limit comments to a maximum of 200 words. Incomprehensible or irrelevant sentences and duplicate comments will be removed. Following receipt of your comment, Keghart.com will send you a verification email to safeguard against spam and impersonation, please click on the link in that email.
Comments are usually posted within 24 hours following your verification.
Your name: *
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Notify me when new comments are posted
All comments Replies to my comment
By: Hovig Nersissian
8 hours 47 min ago
By: Art Hagopian
Second Person Welcome
20 hours 42 min ago
By: Viken L. Attarian
21 hours 57 min ago
By: Zareh Ouzounian
1 day 3 hours ago
Second Potential Candidate
1 day 3 hours ago
By: Vardan Grigoryan
2 days 10 hours ago
One Point Clear
4 days 1 hour ago
KYB Letter to Gary
4 days 2 hours ago
More Information Needed
4 days 15 hours ago
4 days 18 hours ago
Supporting the 'Status Quo'
5 days 4 hours ago
5 days 14 hours ago
1 of 497 ››
Signatures for ArACS petition (189623 times)
Հայերէն գրենք հայկական տառեր օգտագործելով (157312 times)
Free Journalist Nikol Pashinyan (98767 times)
AGBU's Statement Regarding the Protocols (94396 times)
Mandela's Memo to Thomas Friedman About Israel & Palestine (65966 times)
Youth Forum to Discuss Armenia-Diaspora Relations (55019 times)
We Condemn the Turkish-Armenian Agreement (40031 times)
Restitution, Not Retribution (39378 times)
An Energized Diaspora is Entitled to a Democratic Forum (36860 times)
Իրերը Իրենց Անունով Կոչելու Օգուտը (36462 times)
Turkish Defense Minister Unwittingly Confesses Turkey's Guilt in the Armenian Genocide
Forward to the Past: Russia, Turkey, and Armenia’s Fate
Moscow Attacks Armenia
The Conspicuous Silence of the Armenian Academic in Armenia and